This hotel gets 5 stars for the staff who were super helpful and efficient; the location and for the delicious breakfast: their pastries are amazing and they have much to choose from beyond the baked goods.
The 4 stars are based on my own personal preferences, which may not apply to everyone.
I am a light sleeper, so if you are not a light sleeper, definitely go to this hotel. As a light sleeper, the sound proofing could have been better: it was awkward hearing other folks use the bathroom in other rooms.
I am also a person who likes to start the day with quiet, but if you like a boisterous, active start to the day, this is your hotel! As a quiet morning person, it was a lot to walk into the que of people getting their delicious pastries and espresso.
The location of the hotel was great: being so close to wonderful neighborhoods, beautiful architecture and tasty restaurants was very enjoyable.