Compare Hotels with Parking in Garden City

My family (wife and two sons) and I enjoyed our stay in our VIP, 1 King bedroom suite on the 33rd floor. Great location, adjacent to the Grand Station and close to the Chrysler Building. Pros: Nice clean room, lots of space, 1& 1/2 restrooms, two mini refrigerators, nice views from our suite. Cons: The hallways were a bit hot, one of the remote controls was not working, a bit of noise coming from the master bedroom's restroom ceiling and I had to pay an extra $40 per night in order to have access to their Commodore Lounge. If a guest pays for a VIP suite, access to the lounge should be included.

Nice and clean

Great stay. Much better than the crowd frenzy at Times Square

The directions to the pool were not easy to follow. We tried to access it through the elevators that go to the rooms, but once on that floor, we had to take stairs and ask around for the pool.

Check-in was seamless. The staff is always friendly and inviting. I’ve stayed here several times within the last few months and it’s always been a pleasant experience. It’s a 10 minute walk to Penn Station and Madison Square Garden.

The POD felt isolated, safe, and removed from the craziness of the Times Square area; it's unfortunate that the area surrounding it is troubled by homeless people, dirty streets, sirens, and noise. BUT all that is 'far away' once you're ensconced in your small-but-clean room.